BELLAGIO, VARENNA, OR MENAGGIO: WHERE TO BASE YOURSELF ON LAKE COMO
The one decision that shapes the whole trip, settled
All future articles will be posted on our Substack at https://byhande.substack.com/
There is a particular evening that happens to almost everyone planning a first trip to Lake Como. It is late, there are eleven browser tabs open, and all three of the villages you are choosing between look, in photographs, like precisely the same tumble of ochre houses falling into precisely the same blue water. You have read that Bellagio is the one everybody loves and also the one everybody complains about. You have read that Varenna is prettier, or quieter, or possibly both. Menaggio has entered the conversation for reasons you can no longer reconstruct. We have sat in that exact chair. Let us try to make this quick.
First, the thing that matters more than the choice itself. These three villages sit clustered around the fork of the lake, more or less staring at one another across the water, and the ferries between them run all day, every twenty to forty minutes in season, taking somewhere between ten and twenty minutes to cross. A short hop costs a few euros and a day pass is about fifteen. Which means you are not choosing which village to see. You will see all three, easily, probably more than once. You are only choosing which one you want to wake up in and come home to. That takes most of the pressure out of it.
VARENNA, THE ONE WE CHOSE
Varenna sits on the eastern shore, a slim, steep, improbably romantic village of stepped lanes and a lakeside walkway that clings to the rock. It is smaller and calmer than Bellagio, it catches beautiful evening light, and the ruined castle of Vezio sits on the hill above it for anyone who wants a climb and a view.
Its secret weapon, and the reason we settled here for ten nights, is the railway. Varenna has its own station, and the train from Milano Centrale takes about an hour. That means you arrive from the airport without a car, without a transfer, without drama, and it means Milan stays available as an easy day out. Nowhere else on the central lake gives you that. Prices tend to sit a notch below Bellagio, too. When the day boats leave in the late afternoon, Varenna goes quiet and becomes a village again, which is when it is at its very best.
Who it's for: almost everyone. If you want calm, good light, easy arrival, and a base that reaches everything without ever needing a car, start here.
BELLAGIO, THE FAMOUS ONE
Bellagio has been called the pearl of the lake for about as long as people have been writing things down about Como, and it is not an unfair title. It sits right at the fork where the two arms of the lake divide, which gives it the most theatrical position of the three and views down both branches. It is the largest of the trio, with the most hotels, the most shops, the grandest stepped alleyways, and the gardens of Villa Melzi a short walk along the shore.
The trade-off is exactly what you would expect. Bellagio is where the day-trippers, the tour groups, and the cruise excursions all converge, and in the middle of the day in high season it can feel less like a village and more like a queue with a view. The evenings, once the boats have gone, are lovely and considerably livelier than Varenna's.
Who it's for: first-timers who want the definitive Como address, people who like a bit of evening buzz and a wider choice of restaurants, and anyone willing to work around the middle of the day.
MENAGGIO, THE PRACTICAL ONE
Menaggio sits on the western shore and is the least postcard-perfect of the three, which is precisely why some people love it. It is more of a working town, with a proper square, real shops, a good swimming lido, and prices that reflect all of that. It is the natural base for walkers, sitting on the Greenway del Lago, the path that threads north along the old lakeside route through villages and villa gates. It is also the jumping-off point for Lugano, just over the Swiss border by bus.
Who it's for: walkers, swimmers, families, and value hunters. Anyone who would rather have an honest town than a beautiful stage set, and who plans to be out on the water and the trails most days anyway.
THE VERDICT
Choose by temperament, and do not agonize, because the ferry fixes almost any regret by lunchtime.
Want the easy, calm, well-connected choice that arrives by train and quiets down at night? Varenna. Want the famous one with the best position, the most choice, and the liveliest evenings, and you will simply avoid the midday crush? Bellagio. Want the practical, walkable, better-value town with the lido and the trailhead? Menaggio.
Two last practical notes. Whichever you pick, a rental car is optional (for access to smaller villages, etc.). The lake roads are narrow and busy, parking is scarce and expensive, and the boat is faster and more pleasant. And, book somewhere for the whole stay rather than hopping between villages every two nights. Unpacking once and letting the ferries do the moving is the entire luxury of this place, and it is what turns a beautiful lake into somewhere you briefly live.
